Will It Hurt My Gloves or FR? What ASTM D120 and F2621 Testing Means for Skin Products

Every lineman has heard it. “Don’t put that stuff on, it’ll eat your gloves.” So a lot of crews skip sunscreen and bug repellent and take the sunburn and the tick bites instead. That is a bad trade, but the worry behind it is fair. Your rubber gloves and your FR clothing are the gear that keeps you alive. Nothing you put on your skin should put them at risk.

That is why you see ASTM numbers on some skin products. This post explains what ASTM D120 and ASTM F2621 actually cover, what a product test can and cannot tell you, and how to use sun and bug protection around your PPE.

Your gloves: what OSHA already asks of you

Start with the rules you already work under. OSHA’s electrical protective equipment standard, 29 CFR 1910.137, says:

  • Insulating equipment must be inspected for damage before each day’s use and right after any incident that could have damaged it.
  • Insulating gloves get an air test along with that inspection.
  • Gloves that show swelling, softening, hardening, or have turned sticky or inelastic may not be used.
  • Insulating gloves are electrically tested before first issue and every 6 months after that.
  • Insulating equipment must be stored away from light and from other damaging substances and conditions.
  • Protector gloves go over insulating gloves, with limited exceptions.

Swelling, softening and stickiness are the signs of rubber that has been attacked by something. Oils and some solvents are well known for it. So the question “will this lotion hurt my gloves” is the right question to ask.

What ASTM D120 is

ASTM D120 is the standard specification for rubber insulating gloves. It covers how the gloves are made and tested to protect workers from electric shock. It sorts gloves into Type I (not ozone resistant) and Type II (ozone resistant), and into Classes 00 through 4 by voltage. The tests in the spec include AC and DC proof tests, breakdown tests, a chemical test, tensile strength, tear and puncture resistance.

D120 is a glove standard, not a lotion standard. A sunscreen cannot “be” D120. What a skin-product maker can do is put the product on glove rubber and then run the glove tests from D120 to see whether the rubber still holds up. That is what a “D120 tested” claim on a skin product should mean.

What ASTM F2621 is

ASTM F2621 is the standard practice for evaluating how safety products respond in an electric arc exposure. It covers arc-rated gear such as garments, gloves and face shields, and it also covers items that are not arc rated themselves but are used as part of an FR system, which is where a sunscreen or repellent on your skin and shirt fits. The arc exposure itself is run on the ASTM F1959 test setup, the same one used to measure a fabric’s arc rating (ATPV). Flame resistance of fabric is checked separately with the vertical flame test, ASTM D6413.

For a skin product, the practical question is simple. If it is on your skin and soaks into your FR shirt, does that fabric still behave the way it should in an arc or a flame? Testing answers that by putting the product on FR fabric and then running the arc or flame test on that fabric.

What our testing showed

Here is what R&R has on file, in plain terms. Every test below was run by an independent lab: ELTEK International Labs for gloves, and ArcWear with Kinectrics for arc and flame.

Lineman’s rubber gloves (ASTM D120). Type 1, Class 2 rubber insulating gloves were exposed to the product, then put through the 20 kV AC proof test. The gloves passed with I.C. Industrial Sunscreen, I.C. Insect Repellent and I.C. Ivy Block. Some loss in tensile strength was measured after exposure and heat aging; those results are kept on file.

Flame (ASTM D6413). FR twill was coated with I.C. Insect Repellent Lotion, and in a separate test with I.C. Ivy Block. In the vertical flame test neither fabric melted or dripped, and afterflame was half a second or less.

Arc exposure (ASTM F2621, F1959 test setup). We had FR twill tested with each product on it, to see whether the fabric still performs in an arc:

  • Insect repellent lotion (IR3535): the fabric stayed at Arc Category 2. Its rating went from 9.3 to about 8.0 cal/cm², with no ignition or afterflame.
  • Industrial Sunscreen: in a development (scouting) test, the fabric’s arc rating dropped from 10.6 to about 6.9 cal/cm², with no ignition, melting or dripping.
  • Ivy Block: in a scouting test, the fabric came in at about 5 to 6 cal/cm².

What that means on the job: all three are glove-safe when applied as directed. Sunscreen and Ivy Block are FR-compatible when rubbed in: rub them fully into your skin and keep them off your FR clothing, because a heavy coat soaked into the fabric can lower its arc rating. Apply repellent to skin as its label directs.

The sunscreen is a hybrid: non-nano zinc oxide plus organic UV filters. It is full broad spectrum SPF 36 and 80-minute sweat and water resistant, and it rubs in clear. Both repellents are EPA-registered and use IR3535. They repel mosquitoes and ticks for up to 8 hours. EPA Reg. No. 70759-2-91651 (lotion) and 70759-3-91651 (spray).

What a product test does not do

Be clear with your crew about the limits:

  • A product test does not certify your gloves. Your daily inspection and air test, and the 6-month electrical retest, still apply.
  • A product test does not re-rate your FR clothing. Your garment’s arc rating comes from its maker, and anything soaked into the fabric (sweat, oil, lotion) can lower it. Keep skin products on your skin, not on your FR shirt.
  • Results apply to the product that was tested. Do not assume another brand of sunscreen or repellent behaves the same way.
  • If a glove shows swelling, softening or stickiness, it is out of service, no matter what was on your hands.

How to use sun and bug protection around your PPE

  • At the tailboard. Put sunscreen on clean, dry skin: ears, neck, face and the backs of your hands. Apply repellent to exposed skin as its label directs. Do it before you glove up.
  • Let it soak in. Give it a few minutes before your gloves go on. Wipe your palms if they feel slick.
  • Reapply on breaks. Sunscreen at least every 2 hours, and after 80 minutes of sweating. Repellent as its label directs. Take gloves off to do it, not on the pole.
  • Store gloves right. Keep them in their bag, out of the sun, and away from bottles of anything. OSHA’s storage rule is there for a reason.
  • Inspect every day. Air test, look and feel. Any change in the rubber, take them out of service.

For more on sun, ticks and poison ivy on the right-of-way, see our skin care page for linemen and utility crews and Field Notes: Utility & Electrical.

FAQ

Does “D120 tested” mean a sunscreen is approved for use with my gloves?

No. D120 is the glove specification. A D120 test on a skin product means glove rubber was exposed to it and then put through D120 glove tests. Your employer’s PPE program and OSHA’s inspection and retest rules still decide what goes in your bucket.

Is F2621 an arc rating?

No. ASTM F2621 is a practice for checking how safety products respond to an electric arc. It does not set an arc rating. Fabric arc ratings come from ASTM F1959.

Should I use a spray sunscreen on the line?

We make our sunscreen as a lotion, not an aerosol. Whatever you use, check whether it has been tested with your gloves and FR clothing, and follow your company’s PPE program.

Sources

Keep reading

Related articles

More in Workplace Safety & Compliance →

Skin care that cares about the worker and about the work

Try it on the job first.

Free samples for crews, safety managers and buyers. Buy direct, through your distributor or on GSA.